The Axing of Air America
Al Franken Laments Loss of Missoula Outlet
By Jonathan Weber, 3-08-06
Comedian and Air America radio host Al Franken was on the radio in Missoula again this morning - lamenting the decision by Simmons Media Group to scrap Air America and the "progressive talk" format on KNS, and questioning the reasoning behind the decision. While Franken acknowledged that affiliate relationships come and go in the radio business, he called the situation in Missoula "the most shocking of this kind of thing," citing the extremely warm reception he received when he appeared here in January and the excellent ratings the show enjoyed in this market. "It's kind of weird," said Franken. "It doesn't sound like a business decision, it sounds like a political decision."
"There is more fear in this country than I ever realized," Franken continued, adding that the decision in Missoula "felt pretty icky...we thought if we brought the listeners the advertisers would be there."
Interestingly, Franken appeared on the morning show on 103.3 The Trail, which is also owned by Simmons (and also hosts the daily New West Newsminute). Our friend and colleague Dave Cowan, general manager for the Simmons station group in Missoula, deserves a lot of credit for letting Franken have his say.
Like this story? Get more! Sign up for our free newsletters.






Comments
Add your comment below
I really hope you will be open to advertising on a new progressive talk radio station in Missoula and I invite you to visit http://www.airamericamissoula.com and ad your name and pledge your support to the business owner list on the website.
Finally, one more point, this decision, to me, sounds like it came from a right-wing owner in Salt Lake that recently took over. It does not sound like it came from the local people here in Missoula. Please keep in mind that every time we blame the KKNS people here in Missoula for losing Air America, we are potentially hurting people who, although unsuccessful, tried to help our cause. Be careful with the arrows we throw. They might hit people that are willing to help us in the future. If statistics hold true, one would have to assume that, based on Missoula's makeup, at least half of the remaining KKNS staff DOES support our cause. Let's be careful not throw everyone under the bus.
However, be aware that Simmons Media is also the home of X96, an alt-rock radio station in SL. The "radio from hell" morning show on X96 is one of the most left/liberal in the West. They skewer and roast Bush and krew, as well as the Utah state legislature each and every morning. It's fantastic to hear in uber-konservativ Utah...
I have a feeling Simmons either knew it would be "too much blue", so to speak, in his portfolio, or he was pressured "from above" to cancel Air America in Missoula.
Read Bill Frost's blurb on this:
http://www.slweekly.com/article.cfm/mediasplatters
I don't think everyone at KNS wanted to sabotage the station. I also think there were a FEW (for sure less than half) people that worked there that wanted to see it be a success. I believe there were people working there that were middle of the road and could have gone either way. I also think there were people there who were adamantly against the format and had no interest in learning the "dialect". Those people speak their own dialect (I believe neoconish) and have no interest in being open to another point of view. Sign up to show your support at http://www.airamericamissoula.com!
(cut and paste) "don't think" everyone at KNS wanted to sabotage the station. "I also think" there were a FEW (for sure less than half) people that worked there that wanted to see it be a success. "I believe" there were people working there that were middle of the road and could have gone either way. "I also think" there were people there who were adamantly against the format...
David, This is all speculative, heresay, you are using information from a second party. You have no facts to make these statements. Every thing you said was "I THINK", "I BELIEVE" So these are your opinions not facts. Don't you just love second hand news? Where did you get your information about the staff there? From a bleeding heart that lost her job? Remember hell hath no fury... David, you are an educated person, don't believe everything you hear. Why don't you get the facts and talk with the staff there and get the other side of the story, I'll bet you get a better idea of what really went on.
BTW, as to the rest of your argument, how do extremist like Rush Pillbought, or O’lielly attract advertisers? The answer, people reside on both sides of the fence. Some are just slightly tilted to one side, some straddle the middle and some reside in completely different zip codes. In Missoula, NPR is the number on station. We had the second highest per capita votes for Ralph Nader in 2000. We have a HUGE and very active progressive community and a lot of them own businesses too. Progressive Radio will ride again in Missoula. It makes to much business sense. You just have to know and understand the demographic.
May I be so bold to say that I am HAPPY that a station finally stepped up and discontinued airing talk shows that did nothing to promote hate in this country? I wish they would do the same with Rush Limbaugh, Hannity, O'Rielly, etc., too. All of these talk show idiots do nothing but try to be "over the top" and drive a stake between people. While many call it having "a voice." Rush, Franken, O'Rielly, and Colmes will admit it, although only privately, that they are nothing but entertainers (bad one's at that IMHO) that love to get the masses all worked up about a subject and pull in the ratings. This is achieved by going to the extremes - right and left. They love to get Group Think in full swing - it doesn't matter if it is right or not. They just love to pull the strings on their listeners and watch the psycho's duke it out while they collect their hefty paychecks. They simply love it! If memory serves, at one time (before the Limbaugh's and the Franken's) both Democrats and Republican's actually agreed on some subjects from time to time. Today, you would be more likely to see Sunni's and Shiite's getting along than you would see our two major parties. I blame all of the hate-driven talk shows for influencing the press. And the press cannot resist. Seriously, why are "political talk shows" on "news" stations in the first place? The two should be as separate as church and state. When you put the two together, things WILL get clouded. I for one would not spend a dime in advertising any political station to promote hate. They should be ashamed at what they have turned radio into. KKNS SAYING NO TO HATE IS A GOOD THING!!!!
While I have been talking to the press, answering my phone calls and e-mail (well, most of them)I have resisted the urge to post in a public forum until now. That's because I know that my comments are unlikely change the minds of those who have already come to a conclusion about just what is behind the demise of KNS. However I guess that I can no longer ignore the personal attacks on the dedicated and professional staff in our building -- especially the condesending remarks of Mr. Max above:
"KNS was destined to fail; not for lack of advertising support, but for mismanagement and lack of education of "organic" market dynamics. The staff at KNS was the equivalent of having Albertsons staff run The Good Food Store...The sales team and management team did not understand progressive politics or the progressive market. They were tourists in a foreign land with no idea how to speak the dialect and no map to guide their way".
Well Mr. Max, I think that having a business plan to bring the Trail and KNS to an already crowded Missoula radio dial showed some planning and sensitivity to your special community (although I did need to buy a Missoula street map after living for 14 years in tiny, inorganic and regressive Bozeman).
No company EVER has signed on three radio stations from scratch at the same time. Perhaps you know a friend who started a restaurant...maybe the food was great, but the business did not survive. Well, we started three restaurants at the same time...and we entered a market full of burger joints, pizza parlors and steak places and attemped to bring some variety to town.
All the other radio groups in Missoula have the benefit of at least one heritage (15 year+) radio station in their cluster...and the benefit of a long-term sales staff already in place.
Could we have done a better job? Sure. Does our staff (top to bottom) deserve your insightful criticism. Probably not. This will be my first and last post here on this issue...I won't comment on any further replys. From the day KNS signed on, we ran a promo several times a day that included my direct office phone number. It's 329-1888. Sincerely,
Dave
Food for thought though. The neocon-republican political spin machine loves to point out Air America's inability to turn a profit and be a successful business. Simmons, despite their spin to the contrary, obviously has conservative ownership. We are now experiencing their spin on KNS, and a microcosm of the macrocosm. Sorry if some of us are unwilling to watch the truth be distorted once again in our own community.
One more question. I know the Trail was the best performing station, but what about KKVU? How was that doing compared to KNS? Maybe I'm wrong about this, but from what I know, it was the worst performing. I don't believe its format was dropped. Does this support the argument that dropping KNS was only a financial decision?
Again, I am sorry for offending you and your staff Dave. We appreciate the effort some of you gave and wish you the best in moving forward. One last thing though, if we are able to get a new progressive radio station in town, and while we will have you and your staff to thank for peaking our interest, I hope it kicks all three of your stations asses! :')
Now lets get it done.
This doesn't make any sense. FYI, our only goal is to make this work and get the format back onto the airways, not to trash you guys.
I appreciate your candor, but this whole thing just does not make any sense...
Reading New West, subscribing to our newsletters, and participating in a lively, online conversation are all important ways to support our efforts. Thank you, thank you, thank you! So is advertising with us.
For those of you who were frustrated by the apparent lack of support, whether from executives or sales staff, for KNS's alternative vision, know that we're aggresively building a viable business around the kind of content that clearly engages you here and that, if we haven't contacted you, it's only a matter of time.
Building lists of prospects, spending all day every day calling business owners, educating them about our editorial mission and about the many different ways New West can drive business their way, all require a talented, dedicated, motivated staff (nobody has a better one!) and time (there's never enough).
You can help us in three ways:
1. Support our advertisers. Click on their ads. Tell them you saw them on New West.
2. Advertise.
3. Recommend us to every local business you know.
We're not going anywhere, but our ability to grow New West and continue facilitating engaging conversations like these is directly linked to our ability to persuade businesses to advertise.
Please call me or Ingrid Lovitt to figure out how.
Mark Phillips
Director of Sales
New West Network
720-839-9062
Ingrid Lovitt
Director of Marketing
New West Network
406-829-1725
You are no fun at all. You are taking away the very conspiracy theory that is fundamental to the liberals being pissed off. Without it, they have no one to blame. Think about it, if the station was not performing before Simmons came to town, then Simmons really can't be blamed as making a political decision. They just saw an underperforming radio station that needed to be addressed immediately. And, if you, Patrick, cannot be blamed for sabotaging the radio station before Simmons came to town, then, then, then, who can the liberals blame? Their bucket doesn't have a bottom in it! Come on Patrick. Take one for the team! It is just so much more fun to kick you in the teeth, blame you for trying to sabotage a radio station, and act like we came along with you on every advertising meeting with businesses and "know" first hand that you never even tried to sell KKNS and purposely disuaded businesses from buying it. Damn! Without people to blame like you, who would progressive talk radio and its listeners have to bad mouth?
It's just too bad that the high and mighty liberals on this website were not there for you a few months back when it mattered. (OK, secretely, I'm happy they weren't). You see, the last time I checked, it was the responsibility of a business owner (at least a good business owner) to identify marketing tools available to them to build their business. Obviously people like David Max knew about KKNS. Hell, even knew where to find the radio station studios. Would it have been so hard for HIM to ask about advertising and if it were right for HIS business? If he is so ignorant in not knowing how to take advantage of marketing tools at his disposal to build his existing business, he will fail at trying to market a reborn Air America too.
Patrick, take heart, you know first-hand what David Max is up against in his effort to bring back and sell Air America. You will be the one redeemed in the end. Good luck!
Patrick, thank-you for repeating the line because I think we Do tend to forget that we Can always buy satellite radio and be done with it.
Buying satellite radio to hear an alternative viewpoint is somewhat of a cop out that negates the whole purpose of public dialogue,though.
What everybody seens to forget is that the Airwaves are public property to be used for the public good and that having media monopolies that skewer to one side or another defeats democracy and the innovation we need to remain strong, secure and free.
I always make better decisions when I am fully and completely informed so I can't help but question the motives of those who want to censor that information.
My gosh! I NEVER in my wildest dreams expected someone on this site to agree with me on this subject. I hope you weren't being insincere because I really do believe that the Sean Hannity's, Rush Limbaugh's, Al Franken's, and Randy Rhodes', do nothing but fuel a fire of hate. Maybe we are on to something here! Thanks for your encouragement...if that is what it was!
Glad we have New West and the Independent!
email it to all your friends and businesses
http://www.airamericamissoula.com
it will be back
can't stop the tide
the cat's out of the bag now (finally some truth on the public airwaves to combat the lies that are bringing down our great country)
your help will help
thanks
The expression game now is like a match off between the Mormon Tabernacle Choir and one blind deaf mute without any arms and that's no way to preserve a democracy.
Has anybody looked at the Air America Phoenix site? I thought they have a pretty good idea with their fundraising; right wing radio and T.V. was underwritten by the Mellons and Scaifes and their like minded millionaires for a very long time before they so much as broke even.
If a business needs operating capitol to survive, why shouldn't it have a large cushion to begin with?
my humble opinion
I think that you missed the basic premise of this story.
There is a lot of demand for Air America, but no supply.
Your next statement also seems to ring true "so they don't tune in, therego the demand is weak." of the current trend in right-wing radio lossing its overall market share, here in Missoula (NPR and KNS) and across the country. Also most non rightwing folks believe Limbuagh, O'reilly, and Fox "spew so much hate and at times outright lies anyone with half a mind (Or in this case thinks with their own mind) simply tunes out." Under the current approval ratings of our right-wing congress and president "unless air america (rightwing radio) shifts to the middle it's radical days are over."
I didn't realize we (dis)agreed on so much!
This is exectaly why local community dialouge and discourse is so important. All the more reason for establishing an open forum for discussion on the Missoula Airwaves. Part national discussion, part local gathering point, all open to community building and truth sharing!
my humble/not so humble opinion
http://www.airamericamissoula.com