Fairness in Funding
Missoula Demands Its Share of Transportation Dollars
Missoula continually gets the short end when it comes to state and federal transportation funding. Local officials are determined to change that.By Jonathan Weber , 1-20-09
Reserve Street in Missoula. File photo by Emily Haas/NewWest.Net
Missoula officials, long aggrieved at what they consider unfair apportionment of state transportation funds, have approved a strongly worded resolution demanding that the city and county get a fair shake, both on new federal funds flowing from the economic stimulus program and on existing state and federal highway programs.
The resolution, approved by the city-county Transportation Policy Coordinating Committee on Tuesday and printed in full below, details major imbalances in the way the state allocates transportation funding. While greater Missoula accounts for some 8.5% of the state’s population, it is projected to receive just 2.6% of all state and federal transportation funds over the next 25 years. Further, Missoula residents receive only 5-7 cents of benefit for every dollar of state gas tax paid in Missoula.
The resolution comes as state, local and federal officials debate how to spend an anticipated $300 million in federal transportation funds that will flow from the national economic stimulus plan. City officials were furious that the initial state project wish-list included only a single Missoula project - about $3 million for the Scott St. overpass - out of some $1.5 billion in projects statewide that were cited as stimulus program priorities.
A few additional projects, most involving repairs on I-90, have since been added to the list, but the total for Missoula still comes to just $28 million.
While the geography and political balance of power in the state all but assure that rural areas will get more than a strictly “fair” share - and Missoula, as one of the largest and wealthiest communities in the state, has the resources to do a lot on its own - the proposed stimulus package spending apparently pushed local officials to a new level of frustration. Numerous projects in Missoula, including a new bridge on Russell Street, the reconstruction of the Russell and Third Street corridors, and possible rail transit initiatives, are critical to the healthy long-term development of the region and yet are far beyond the financial means of the city and county on their own.
Following is the full text of the resolution, which was signed by County Commissioners Bill Carey and Michele Landquist, Mayor John Engen, Stacey Rye of the city council, Don MacArthur of the planning board, and Andy Sponseller of the Missoula Urban Transportation District. Doug Moeller of the Montana Department of Transportation abstained.
Resolution No. 2009-1
A Resolution of the Transportation Policy Coordinating Committee of the Missoula Metropolitan Planning Organization calling for an equitable distribution of federal and state transportation revenue, both as a part of the proposed Federal Economic Stimulus package and as a part of ongoing transportation investment in Montana.
WHEREAS, in 2000 the residents of the Missoula Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO) comprised 8.5 percent of the population of the State of Montana and that percentage will likely go up with the 2010 census; and
WHEREAS, as Dr. Larry Swanson, the Director of the O’Connor Center for the Rocky Mountain West, told the Legislature’s Revenue Committee in December 2007, “Cities in Montana have become the settings if not the engines of economic growth, diversification, and advancement, as is the case in the larger regions. They are growing centers of education, health care, entertainment, culture, business, and finance. The greatest growth and prosperity will center and expand in cities of quality. Tend to and plan well for this growth;” and
WHEREAS, from 1990 to 2005 Missoula has had the tenth highest rate of population growth, the fourth highest rate of employment growth, the fourth highest rate of total personal income growth, and the second highest rate of per capita income growth of the 30 regional centers west of the Mississippi with comparable populations; and
WHEREAS, an improved transportation infrastructure is needed to sustain Missoula as an Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) carbon monoxide (CO) maintenance area, to enhance our ability to be redesignated as an EPA PM – 10 (particulate matter) maintenance area, to avoid being added as an EPA PM – 2.5 (fine particulate matter) non-attainment area, and to support the Missoula Health Department’s strategic planning goal to improve our healthy built environment; and
WHEREAS, the only transportation project sponsored by a Missoula MPO member local government that was placed on the Governor’s stimulus package list is the Scott Street Overpass at $2.973 million; and
WHEREAS, investment in the Scott Street Overpass represents 0.19 percent of the approximately $1.6 billion proposed by the Governor for transportation projects statewide; and
WHEREAS, after taking into account obligation limitations and rescissions, the State of Montana has received an average of $284 million in federal funds from all Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) and Federal Transit Administration (FTA) sources for highway and transit improvements in federal fiscal years 2005-2008; and
WHEREAS, Missoula’s recently adopted Long Range Transportation Plan federal revenue forecast, which was provided by the Montana Department of Transportation (MDT), calls for an average of $7.4 million annually in federal funds for the MPO from all FHWA and FTA sources for highway and transit improvements over the next 28 years; and
WHEREAS, assuming funding levels remain the same Missoula’s federal funds are projected to be only 2.61 percent of all FHWA and FTA funds coming to Montana for highway and transit improvements between 2009 and 2035; and
WHEREAS, the average Montana resident receives at least $2.30 in benefit for every $1.00 spent on federal gas tax; and
WHEREAS, this increased benefit is entirely appropriate given the large amount of federal land in Western Montana, the distances between Montana communities, and the importance of Montana’s highway system including hubs like Missoula to interstate commerce; and
WHEREAS, the average Missoula MPO resident receives only $0.71 in benefit for every $1.00 spent on federal gas tax, which is less that one third of the State average; and
WHEREAS, in Fiscal Year 2006 $30.6 million and $41.2 million in State gas tax was collected in the City of Missoula and in Missoula County, respectively (While all of the fuel subject to this tax was delivered to Missoula County, some of this fuel may have been used outside of the County.); and
WHEREAS, the City and County received a total of $2.5 million in State gas tax revenue in FY 2007 (Includes City and County apportionments, contract maintenance performed by the City for MDT, and State match of Federal funds. Does not include State gas tax funds spent by MDT on highway operations and maintenance within the MPO area.); and
WHEREAS, the average Missoula MPO resident received approximately $0.05 to $0.07 on every $1.00 spent on State gas tax paid in Missoula; and
WHEREAS, as is evidenced by the recently adopted Long Range Transportation Plan, MDT has no plans to invest in and thus has not developed projects and is not developing projects to improve Reserve Street (US Highway 93), Brooks Street (US Highway 12), 5th and 6th Streets (US Highway 12) Madison Street (US Highway 12), or Broadway (US Highway 12 and Interstate 90 Business) between 2009 and 2035 despite safety and congestion issues on those facilities and despite the importance of these facilities to Missoula’s and thus the State’s economy; and
WHEREAS, while the recently completed Highway 93 Corridor Study identifies the segment of Highway 93 between Blue Mountain and Reserve Street as the most congested segment of this critical corridor and the City and County worked with FHWA to complete an Environmental Impact Statement for improvements in this segment, MDT has not pursued development of the resulting project and considers it a local issue; and
WHEREAS, MDT has used its authority to require the City of Missoula to expand the scope and thus the cost of the Russell Street project in order to, in part, lessen congestion on an MDT facility (Reserve Street), obligating federal urban funds allocated to Missoula that could be used to develop other critically needed improvements; and
WHEREAS, the dearth of project development activity and thus “shovel ready” projects within the boundaries of the Missoula MPO places Missoula at a competitive disadvantage as opportunities like the proposed Federal Economic Stimulus package present themselves; and
WHEREAS, the dearth of transportation investment within the boundaries of the Missoula MPO threatens to effectively idle one of Montana’s key “engines of economic growth” during a critical period in Montana history.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Transportation Policy Coordinating Committee of the Missoula Metropolitan Planning Organization that federal and state transportation revenue should be distributed equitably in Montana, both as a part of the proposed Federal Economic Stimulus package and as a part of ongoing federal and state transportation investment in Montana.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Committee requests that the Governor, the Legislature, and the Transportation Commission revise funding programs and formulas to ensure that Missoulians receive an equitable share of federal and state transportation funding so that all Montanans receive the benefits of economic development that would result from this investment.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Committee requests that Montana’s Congressional delegation continue to work diligently to ensure that Missoulians receive an equitable share of federal transportation funding, both in the proposed Economic Stimulus package and in the reauthorization of the Surface Transportation Act.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Committee requests that the State Transportation Commission meet soon and regularly in Missoula to discuss transportation investment in the community.
Dated this 20th day of January, 2009
Like this story? Get more! Sign up for our free newsletters.






Comments
Add your comment below
Go ahead , whine away all you "talk about it ,don't build it " folks while the other towns get the roads , the jobs and the pleasant commutes and we get the congestion of Reserve St. because we can't build Russell St. We asked for this Missoula so quit bitchin.
"Silly road diet" - actually the errors with the West Broadway project were with the transitions, not with building "silly road diets" (something that has been done for decades in crazy radical places like Iowa). Still, it's worth remembering that no pedestrians have been killed on that stretch of Broadway since the project was finished. That's also the experience elsewhere. Now people who want to use the crosswalk to walk from the Broadway Building to Taco John's can actually get drivers to stop for them. Crazy, I know...
Surprisingly, Missoulians don't mind spending money on FIXING roads. But not all of us fall for the highway builder's dream of building new 5-lane roads for a fool's paradise level of service A, at a vast waste of tax payers' money. I love the 5 lanes through Sun River. Unlikely that we'll ever see enough traffic to "justify" those lanes, which were pitched to local citizens as a safety improvement. Meanwhile, Sun Riverites have a wide fast highway to cross to get from one side to the other. Cool.
Spending road construction funds in "those communities that actually build roads." As it happens, plain old roads in communities (not the select few roads on the Federal Aid System), often get built through development processes and and property taxes. Even Marxist Missoula actually builds roads.
"shove bike paths" -- actually, bike paths are popular in many places other than Missoula. Communist Great Falls has one of the best trail networks in the state, something that makes them quite proud. Socialist Lewistown recently acquired a bunch of railroad right of way for their dream of a 14-mile trail network. Crazy farmers. Seeley Lake folks seem content with their path (but when MDT tried to ram a big road expansion through, their citizens got busy signing petitions and threatening to sue the State). Those radical eco-freaks in such towns shouldn't get any funds.
"We get the congestion of Reserve St. because we can't build Russell St." Wrong. Reserve St. is congested because the Primary System highway funding was wasted on what turned out to be a 5-lane commercial strip. That wasn't how it was sold to the community. It was supposed to be a bypass on the west side of Missoula to relieve congestion on Brooks. But wait, now that we wasted the highway money to serve nice new big box stores that take business away from existing stores, we've got car nuts pushing for a NEW bypass west of Reserve. It must be great to have a short memory -- and not to have to worry about whether Missoula falls back into non-attainment for Carbon Monoxide and lives with sanctions from EPA. Too bad some of us have long memories and know stuff, I guess.
/JW
Don't get me started...I have a bunch of issues with Missoula, it just raises my blood pressure.