Your local online source


MITTING THEIR PANTS

On Mitt Romney’s Chances in 2008


By Tracy Medley, 6-20-06

By all accounts, Mitt Romney is a whip-smart man of integrity with unique skills and qualities that would seem a perfect fit for the presidency. He is well liked and respected on both sides of the aisle and is widely considered a good man, but his potential bid for the presidency in 2008 just might force the GOP to deal with some major underlying tension between its devoted Mormon and evangelical bases.

Mormons overwhelmingly vote Republican, gave 95 percent of their vote to George W. Bush in the 2004 election and share the religious right’s goals concerning “traditional family values.” However, they soon may face some tough decisions about their political loyalties if their evangelical brothers choose to dismiss Romney principally because of his religious beliefs.

Most traditional religions reject the validity of Mormon baptisms, but few religions are as critical of the Latter-day Saint faith as evangelical and fundamentalist Christian groups. They have repeatedly labeled Mormonism as a “cult” and take every opportunity to deride the LDS church through written and widely distributed literature. Put most plainly, fundamentalist Christians, when not pandering to Mormons for votes against gay marriage, abortion and stem-cell research, do not believe that Mormons are Christian at all. Moreover they deem Mormonism a “false religion” and their members guilty of blasphemy.

According to an article by Amy Sullivan, published in Washington Monthly, “In 2004, Mormons were specifically excluded for participation in the National Day of Prayer organized by Shirley Dobson (wife of James Dobson, leader of the conservative Christian organization Focus on the Family) because their theology was found to be incompatible with Christian beliefs.”

However, when it comes to publicly criticizing Romney specifically for being a Mormon, few evangelicals have come out swinging.

In fact, Charles Colson, a prominent evangelical leader told the Weekly Standard that he “could in very good conscience support Romney,” but quickly made sure to clarify his position later in a radio address, “I respect Mormons and work with them, but we can’t gloss over our fundamental differences.”

Ultimately, fundamentalists will have to decide if those “differences” negate Romney’s demonstrated ability as a worthy candidate and if they’re willing to alienate their LDS comrades at the risk of dividing their Party.

Will Mormon Republicans stage a massive walkout on the Republican Party if Romney’s bid is rejected? Probably not. But it might begin to loosen the Republican death grip around the Mormon throat—and maybe that’s not such a bad thing.

If Romney does make it past the evangelical snake-pit in the primary races, there is still the bigger question, looming large: Is America ready for a Mormon president?

Senator Ted Kennedy (D) of Massachusetts, when asked by the Atlantic Monthly whether he thought that Romney’s Mormonism would hurt him in a national campaign said it best, “The answer is no,” he said, “we’ve moved on. That died with my brother Jack.”



Like this story? Get more! Sign up for our free newsletters.

Back to the NewWest Missoula page

Comments

Add your comment below

By Larry, 6-20-06
By Tracy Medley, 6-20-06
By murphy, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By murphy, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By murphy, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By Kevin, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By murphy, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By Chris, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By murphy, 6-20-06
By murphy, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By murphy, 6-20-06
By Jason, 6-20-06
By Jerry, 6-20-06
By murphy, 6-20-06
By abdu jones, 6-21-06
By mike, 6-21-06
By Myclob, 6-21-06
By Myclob, 6-21-06
By Myclob, 6-21-06
By Myclob, 6-21-06
By Myclob, 6-21-06
By Myclob, 6-21-06
By Tracy Medley, 6-21-06
By LH, 6-21-06
By murphy, 6-21-06
By LH, 6-21-06
By Maw, 6-21-06
By murphy, 6-21-06
By William, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By murphy, 6-21-06
By Larry, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By murphy, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By Larry, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By Larry, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By Larry, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By Eric, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By Myclob, 6-21-06
By Myclob, 6-21-06
By Lynn, 6-21-06
By Lynn, 6-21-06
By Lynn, 6-21-06
By Lynn, 6-21-06
By Lynn, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-21-06
By Lynn, 6-21-06
By Lynn, 6-21-06
By Jerry, 6-22-06
By Myclob, 6-22-06
By myclob, 6-22-06
By William, 6-22-06
By Lynn, 6-22-06
By Jerry, 6-22-06
By myclob, 6-22-06
By myclob, 6-22-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By myclob, 6-23-06
By Larry, 6-23-06
By Larry, 6-23-06
By Larry, 6-23-06
By Larry, 6-23-06
By Larry, 6-23-06
By Larry, 6-23-06
By Larry, 6-23-06
By Barry, 6-23-06
By Larry, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By myclob, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By Jerry, 6-23-06
By Aaron, 6-23-06