By LetBuffaloRoam, New West Unfiltered 2-08-08
Montana needs legislation to order all state agencies to manage wild buffalo no differently than any other wildlife species. Even wolves are treated with considerably more respect, though they are seriously mistreated and misunderstood.
If the legislature can't stand up to the livestock industry, the issue should be taken directly to the voters by initiative.
This column drips with propaganda. Saying that the 53 are part of American's last wild bison is completely misleading.
The population of the YNP bison herd size is reaching near historic highs. The range can only support about 3000. The management compact among Montana, Wyoming, and the federal government recognizes that bison will outgrow any established range unless culled by starvation, predation, disease, or management. That management takes the form of hunting and selected capture with slaughter. Merely increasing the range delays until tomorrow those decsions that are faced today. Even Ted Turner culls his herd.
Calling these animals 'wild' after being mere zoo animals for summer tourists is a bit of a stretch. The BFC continually uses the word 'wild' without ever having defined what that means.
Here is a listing of 'wild' bison herds that does repeat the false statement about the YNP herd being the last: http://www.editthis.info/wildbison/List_of_Wild_Bison_Herds
Interesting, there were about 20 "wild bison" left in Yellowstone in 1902. 21 domestic bison from Texas and Montana were brought in to add to the population by breeding. Where did the "pure wild buffalo" come from in 2008??????? Surely they aren't 106 years old.
Comment By Craig Moore, 2-10-08I wonder why the BFC ignores the facts. For a list of the wild bison herds see: http://www.editthis.info/wildbison/List_of_Wild_Bison_Herds
Comment By Craig Moore, 2-10-08NW's Akismet keeps blocking my comments. I'll try again. To view the link below, substitute 'dot' with '.'
I wonder why the BFC continually ignores the facts. See the truth about wild bison herds here:
wwwdoteditthisdotinfo/wildbison/List_of_Wild_Bison_Herds
The bison herd in Yellowstone was supplemented, but it was with other bison. They refer to them as the "last wild bison" for a number of reasons--one of which is that the majority of other bison herds are either managed like cattle or, if they are free-roaming on refuges, they have strains of livestock in them. The Yellowstone bison population may be the last US herd that is 100% Bison bison without livestock DNA mixed in.
Craig, how did they come up with the 3000 cap on bison? How can the region support 14,000 or 15,000 elk but only 3,000 bison? Why are the elk allowed to roam outside the park and are not shipped to slaughter even though they have transmitted brucellosis to cattle? Why are elk fed on the National Elk Refuge but bison are viewed as interlopers that need to be controlled and removed? I don't want to see elk rounded up like cattle and sent to slaughter but current bison management policies are illogical. And they're using my tax dollars to treat wildlife like livestock in my national park and national forests. Your comment about bison numbers returning to "historic highs" seems way off. There used to be somewhere around 30 million across the US--how is 4500 in the YNP area even remotely at historic levels? I have no idea what historic levels of WILD bison you are talking about. And your referral to them as zoo animals because tourists go to Yellowstone is ridiculous. I guess you're one of the tourists who kicks a bison to get it to stand up for a picture because you think of the wildlife there as an exhibit for your pleasure instead of part of our natural heritage. I suppose all the wildlife there are zoo animals to you then--grizzlies, wolves, elk, deer, marmots..you name it, all zoo animals in your estimation. Or is it just bison? And if so, why just bison? Why are we just managing bison as cattle?
Oh my, where to begin. I believe that the BFDs are the only ones who actually buy into the only 100% buffalo in the US.
In the first place as far as historic buffs go, what we have now is primarily plains buffalo, only the remnant herd in Pelican Valley are the mountain buffs as I understand, and they are of course mixed now too.
No matter how many buffs roamed the plains, they were not all in one little spot in Yellowstone. There simply is not enough feed for them in the numbers now present and they leave, and please don't say they are following their historic migration paths, unless you think they are headed for Texas! Now if you want buffalo in your yard, that is fine with me, but I'm sure your neighbors are going to want them kept out fo theiers.
Each buffalo is approximately double the size of an elk. The nothern herd is now down by approximately 70%, (6000 over a year ago) and probably more by the time winter is over....if they ever decide to count again.
When they brought in the buffs they never intended that the herd get so large, and they became alarmed when the number was around 1000 in 1920. The buffalo have essentially no natural enemies, and are unaffected by brucellosis so they continue to grow without controls, that is their nature. That is why hundreds of thousands roamed an empty country before the white man came, if a tribe ran a few thousand off a cliff, it made no difference overall.
Brucellosis is a serious disease and NPS refuses to deal with it seriously, so osmeone else has to.
There is an excellent article on the whole thing in the latest issue of "Range Magazine" by Dave Skinner. Well worth trying to find a copy and read it.
Well, if you're going to be persnickety about it...the American Bison is not a buffalo. There are two subspecies: Wood Bison (Bison bison athabascae) and Plains Bison (Bison bison bison). I haven't come across anything referring to "mountain buffalo" other than your comment of course. The "mixed" comment refers to mixing with livestock, not with subspecies of bison. That is an important distinction. Second, there were millions of bison, not hundreds of thousands. Third, they do have important seasonal migrations--just like thousands of other wildlife species--generally revolving around food resources and mating or calving behaviors. This is not new. This is not the same as long-distance migrations. Fourth, if brucellosis is such a serious issue than why aren't elk hazed and shipped off to slaughter? Wild bison have not transmitted to cattle; there have been numerous cases of elk transmitting it to livestock. Fifth, humans prey upon bison--are we not a natural "enemy"? Wolves and grizzlies also prey upon them.
This article was printed from www.newwest.net at the following URL: http://www.newwest.net/main/article/yellowstone_np_captures_53_of_americas_last_wild_bison/