Congress and Elections 2010

Western Pols Quick to Denounce Passage of Health Care Bill

And within the expected negative statements from western politicians are embedded political codes designed to shape how voters think.

By Jill Kuraitis, 3-22-10

 
 

It took less than five minutes Sunday night after Congress passed the health care reform bill for the press releases to fly - a sure sign they were written well in advance. No surprise there.

Neither is it surprising that Idaho elected officials and candidates for those offices are unhappy with national health reform; they’ve been clear and consistent about it for months.

Idaho Gov. Butch Otter’s statement is the most specific and least inflammatory of the bunch, except for the slightly snarky headline punctuation:

GOVERNOR REACTS TO HOUSE APPROVAL OF HEALTHCARE “REFORM” LEGISLATION
“States like Idaho are working hard to create public-private healthcare partnerships and facilitate local solutions. Big federal programs aren’t the answer. It’s even more important now for patients and practitioners, hospitals and health insurers, employers and employees to work together, because Congress and the White House got it wrong. All this will do is keep states and the marketplace from making healthcare more affordable and accessible while imposing a legacy of untold debt on our children and grandchildren.”

Idaho 1st District Congressman Walt Minnick’s statement reads in part:
MINNICK: RESPONSIBILITY TO START WORKING TOGETHER
“I voted no today because I was elected to listen to my constituents, seek the best possible information and use my best judgment to make the right decision for Idaho.

It was a difficult vote because, like all Idahoans, I truly do care about improving the health-insurance system, about reducing costs and about improving care. But I voted against this bill because it is critical to the long-term fiscal health of the country that we not get this wrong.

No one should ever be elected to be a blind loyalist to a political party, on any issue, but we owe the people we represent nothing less than our deep commitment to work together on the issues facing this nation. The people of Idaho have such a commitment from me.” (The full text of Minnick’s press release is below.)

Idaho 2nd District Congressman Mike Simpson’s press release uses a trigger word – “takeover” in its headline:
SIMPSON VOTES AGAINST NATIONAL HEALTH CARE TAKEOVER
Idaho Congressman Mike Simpson voted no tonight on HR 3590, legislation that represents the first step to a government takeover of the healthcare system.  Despite Simpson’s strong opposition and repeated efforts to defeat the bill, this bill passed the House by a final vote of 219-212.
“There is no doubt that this legislation will be challenged in court,” said Simpson.  “Beyond the question of its legality, this bill will ultimately damage the health care system in the United States while adding another $2 to 3 trillion to our national debt. At this time, I encourage all Idahoans to support Governor Otter in his effort to challenge its constitutionality in court.”

Congressman Simpson has supported a number of commonsense health reform bills that have been introduced in Congress, such as H.R. 1086, the HEALTH Act, and H.R. 2607, the Small Business Healthcare Fairness Act, to name just a few.

“Many have said we are the party of ‘NO,’ but that is simply not the case,” said Simpson. “We have offered several commonsense alternatives that will actually bring down the cost of health care. I am extremely disappointed to see that once again, the Democrats have failed to listen to the American people and chosen to push a partisan takeover of health care instead of passing effective health reform that everyone could support. (The full text of Simpson’s press release is below.)

Idaho Republican Party Chairman Norm Semanko’s statement also employs political code techniques such as failing to refer to President Obama as the President, Rep. Nancy Pelosi as the Speaker of the House (and using her name at all, a synonym for “Satan” in this red state.) The capitalization of “American People” is sometimes used to put special emphasis on the phrase, a trigger which could influence feelings of patriotism. These tricks of the trade are frequently used.

“Today’s disastrous vote on the health care bill in the House of Representatives demonstrates how out of touch Barack Obama, Nancy Pelosi and the Congressional Democrats are with the American People.  Instead of starting over and working on a bipartisan agreement, Barack Obama and Nancy Pelosi chose to ram through a bill that costs way too much money, puts government in control of personal health decisions, cuts Medicare, and grows government—while doing nothing to control the skyrocketing costs of healthcare.

The American people want true health care reform that isn’t about politics, but rather about the families, businesses and economy of the nation. Obama, Pelosi and the Democrats in Congress have continued to fail the American people, and today’s vote is proof that they still aren’t listening. Democrats can expect to pay the consequences at the polls in November, here in Idaho and across the nation.”

Candidates for the Republican nomination for Idaho’s 1st Congressional district seat - the winner will challenge incumbent Democrat Rep. Walt Minnick – also issued statements. Raul Labrador’s uses an old trick of using the term “Democrat” when the proper form is “Democratic” – probably designed to make “Democrat” a dirty word and to disassociate “democratic” with just one party.

Labrador also invokes his opinion that the bill is unconstitutional, a frequent cry from the right.

RAUL LABRADOR’S STATEMENT ON PASSAGE OF DEMOCRAT HEALTH BILLS
“Tonight, with a majority of Americans opposing the government take-over of health care, Democrats in Washington passed a bill that is deeply flawed. I agree that Americans need affordable and quality health care, but considering the current state of the economy, I do not believe that small businesses and middle class families benefit from paying an additional half trillion dollars in new taxes.

I believe that this bill steps away from personal, private coverage and choice, to a Washington-controlled healthcare system that will limit choice, restrict innovation, and harm competition.

This bill endangers the U.S. Constitution and the principle of limited government through mandates forcing Americans to purchase health care coverage deemed acceptable by the government or face fines. This bill restricts personal choice and will shamefully force Americans to purchase plans they did not want or could not afford.”

Labrador’s most serious primary opponent, Vaughn Ward, also invokes a view of the bill as unconstitutional:
“Walter Minnick’s party has done it again.  Though he voted “no” on the health care bill, he did nothing to work with Republicans to stop this unconstitutional bill from being forced on the people.  Idahoans are frustrated and outraged that the guy they sent to Congress to protect us could not deliver, again.  It is time to remove Walter Minnick and help pull the gavel of power from his boss, Nancy Pelosi.  If the people of Idaho elect me to Congress, I will forge a new era of conservative leadership and I will work tirelessly to repeal this unconstitutional legislation.  I will represent the families of Idaho and propose legislation that reforms health care using market driven approaches.  These approaches will relieve the burden on our small businesses and put Idahoans back to work.”

Minnick voted “no” along with 33 other Democrats and every Republican in the House, but that didn’t stop Ward from trying to pin the bill’s passage on him.  In this election year, Republicans are eager to place blame on Democrats for perceived injustices, mistakes, and outrages, and are counting on anti-federal-interference sentiment to boost their campaigns.

Utah’s 1st Congressional District Rep. Rob Bishop uses particularly pointed code language in his release, BISHOP LAMENTS DEMOCRAT HIJACKING OF INDIVIDUAL LIBERTIES; HISTORIC HEALTHCARE TAKEOVER PASSES THE HOUSE

Tonight, Congressman Rob Bishop (UT-01) cast a “no” vote for the Democrat takeover of healthcare, H.R. 3590.  Despite significant bipartisan opposition, Speaker Pelosi wrangled 219 Democrat members to vote in favor of the bill- just enough needed to send the bill to the President’s desk for signature.

“I am proud to say that I was one of the 212 Members of Congress who opposed the Democrat’s freedom-robbing healthcare bill.  Poor process produces a poor product and this trillion dollar tragedy is about as bad as they come.  From the very start, this bill was on course to be one of the most historic examples of why we must restore a balance of power in Washington.

“Over the past year, Democrats consistently turned a deaf ear to the American people and to the numerous alternatives offered by Republicans, proving that it was not about passing the best possible bill, but instead about increasing government intrusion into the lives of all Americans.  This abuse of power is exactly what the Founding Fathers sought to prevent when they drafted the Constitution.” (The full text of Bishop’s statement is below.)

Colorado’s two Republican representative voted with the rest of their party, while Democrat Betsy Markey, who was a wild card, voted yes despite having voted against earlier versions of the health care bill. The rest of the Colorado delegation are all Democrats who joined Markey with yes votes. According to Denver’s NBC affiliate 9News, Republican Rep. Mike Coffman said, “This stuff is just crazy and it will put Americans on a dangerous road.”

PRESS RELEASES IN FULL:
U.S. Rep. Walt Minnick released the following statement today after voting on the health reform package before the House of Representatives:

“I voted no today because I was elected to listen to my constituents, seek the best possible information and use my best judgment to make the right decision for Idaho.

It was a difficult vote because, like all Idahoans, I truly do care about improving the health-insurance system, about reducing costs and about improving care. But I voted against this bill because it is critical to the long-term fiscal health of the country that we not get this wrong.

Nevertheless, I remain committed to working on what comes next:

• We must enact comprehensive tort reform.
• We must bring more providers to rural communities.
• We must increase the number of primary-care physicians.
• We must improve mental and physical care for our returning military veterans.
• We must work to reduce the costs within the health care system.
• We must decrease the Medicare rate disparity that hurts states like Idaho.
• We must shift the basis for medical payments from procedures to outcomes.

And I offer my firm commitment to hold the administration accountable for their promise that this legislation will not add to the deficit.

Whether you supported or opposed this bill, surely you agree that we must now work together to move beyond the rhetoric and anger that has so divided our nation. There are too many important issues facing this nation for us to allow the divisions created by this vote to remain beyond this vote.

No one should ever be elected to be a blind loyalist to a political party, on any issue, but we owe the people we represent nothing less than our deep commitment to work together on the issues facing this nation. The people of Idaho have such a commitment from me.”

Simpson Votes Against National Health Care Takeover

Idaho Congressman Mike Simpson voted no tonight on HR 3590, legislation that represents the first step to a government takeover of the healthcare system.  Despite Simpson’s strong opposition and repeated efforts to defeat the bill, this bill passed the House by a final vote of 219-212.

“There is no doubt that this legislation will be challenged in court,” said Simpson.  “Beyond the question of its legality, this bill will ultimately damage the health care system in the United States while adding another $2 to 3 trillion to our national debt. At this time, I encourage all Idahoans to support Governor Otter in his effort to challenge its constitutionality in court.”

Congressman Simpson has supported a number of commonsense health reform bills that have been introduced in Congress, such as H.R. 1086, the HEALTH Act, and H.R. 2607, the Small Business Healthcare Fairness Act, to name just a few.

“Many have said we are the party of ‘NO,’ but that is simply not the case,” said Simpson. “We have offered several commonsense alternatives that will actually bring down the cost of health care. I am extremely disappointed to see that once again, the Democrats have failed to listen to the American people and chosen to push a partisan takeover of health care instead of passing effective health reform that everyone could support.”

Simpson and 70 of his colleagues have cosponsored H.R. 1086, the HEALTH Act. This bill would implement effective medical malpractice reform and put an end to junk lawsuits by placing caps on non-economic damages and limiting attorney fees. This bill would save as much as $120 billion in wasteful spending by stemming the practice of defensive medicine.

Simpson is also a cosponsor of H.R. 2607, the Small Business Healthcare Fairness Act, which would allow small businesses to band together through associations to buy health care coverage. Large corporations and labor unions already leverage their size and buying power to secure lower premiums and rates when buying health insurance for their employees and members. This bill would give America’s small businesses the same advantages to make health care coverage for their employees more affordable.

 

In addition, Simpson supports reforms to prohibit insurers from denying coverage to people because of pre-existing condition as well as reforms to make the purchase of health insurance for individuals tax-exempt like it is for employer-sponsored insurance.  He also supports prescription drug re-importation, which would control prescription drug costs by allowing Americans to buy FDA-approved prescription drugs from places such as Canada and Europe where drugs are sold for much less money.

“I also believe that we need to do more as a country to focus on prevention and early intervention,” said Simpson. “If we truly want to control the cost of healthcare, individuals must be part of the solution by taking an active role in our overall health.”

BISHOP LAMENTS DEMOCRAT HIJACKING OF INDIVIDUAL LIBERTIES; HISTORIC HEALTHCARE TAKEOVER PASSES THE HOUSE

Tonight, Congressman Rob Bishop (UT-01) cast a “no” vote for the Democrat takeover of healthcare, H.R. 3590.  Despite significant bipartisan opposition, Speaker Pelosi wrangled 219 Democrat members to vote in favor of the bill- just enough needed to send the bill to the President’s desk for signature.

“I am proud to say that I was one of the 212 Members of Congress who opposed the Democrat’s freedom-robbing healthcare bill.  Poor process produces a poor product and this trillion dollar tragedy is about as bad as they come.  From the very start, this bill was on course to be one of the most historic examples of why we must restore a balance of power in Washington.

“Over the past year, Democrats consistently turned a deaf ear to the American people and to the numerous alternatives offered by Republicans, proving that it was not about passing the best possible bill, but instead about increasing government intrusion into the lives of all Americans.  This abuse of power is exactly what the Founding Fathers sought to prevent when they drafted the Constitution.” (The full text of Bishop’s statement is below.)

“The State of Utah has realized the need for true healthcare reform and started a process based on the needs of the state’s unique demographics that would have provided viable options for all Utahns.  This vote will stop Utah’s efforts as well as those of other states working to provide tailored alternatives to this massive one-size-fits-all assault on freedom and choice. The destruction of Utah’s creative alternative is the real tragedy.

“Today is not the proudest day of this institution and I am committed, more than ever, to work toward getting this country back on track by rebuilding individual liberty and restoring the principles of Federalism on which this country was founded,” said Congressman Bishop.


Among other things, this legislation will:

· add $569.2 billion in tax increases

· cut Medicare by $523.5 billion

· add $48 billion more for Medicaid

· create $17 billion in new taxes on Americans who do not comply with the individual mandate

· force $52 billion in new taxes on employers that do not provide health coverage deemed “acceptable” or “affordable” by government bureaucrats




Like this story? Get more! Sign up for our free newsletters.

NEW WEST FEATURES                                                                 More>>

Advertisement

Comments

By Tom von Alten, 3-22-10
By Mitch, 3-22-10
By mike crill, 3-22-10
By mike crill, 3-22-10
By Mickey Garcia, 3-22-10
By TomK, 3-22-10
By Mike, 3-23-10
By Mickey Garcia, 3-23-10
By bearbait, 3-23-10
By Mickey Garcia, 3-23-10
By Mickey Garcia, 3-24-10
By bearbait, 3-24-10
By Mickey Garcia, 3-24-10
By James Bowen, 3-25-10
By bearbait, 3-25-10
By Mickey Garcia, 3-25-10
By thedirtydemocrat, 3-25-10
By jwscotch, 3-25-10
By bearbait, 3-25-10
By bearbait, 3-25-10
By thedirtydemocrat, 3-25-10
By Tom von Alten, 3-25-10
By thedirtydemocrat, 3-25-10
By jwscotch, 3-25-10
By pthedirtydemocrat, 3-25-10
By Mickey Garcia, 3-25-10
By thedirtydemocrat, 3-25-10
By Mickey Garcia, 3-26-10
By Mickey Garcia, 3-26-10

Comment policy:

NewWest.Net encourages robust and lively, but civil participation from our readers. By posting here, you agree to the NewWest.Net terms of service. You agree to keep your comments on topic, respectful and free of gratuitous profanity. Contributions that engage in personal attacks, racism, sexism, bigotry, hatred or are otherwise patently offensive will be subject to removal.

Other than using a filter that scans for comment spam, we do not moderate contributions before they are posted and we do not review every thread, so we ask that you help us in keeping the discussions civil and appropriate. Please email info@newwest.net to notify us of comments that may violate these guidelines. Thanks for your help and cooperation. Click here for some tips on how to best interact on NewWest.Net.

Your Comment

Name

Email

Remember my name and email address.

Notify me of follow-up comments.

 

Marketplace